Charlestown Township, Chester County, PA

 
What's new? (Home)
Search this site
Site Overview
About Charlestown
 Index to Gov't Info
 General Info
 Organizations
 The early days
 Photo Albums
Surplus & Needs
Neighborhood links
Notify me of updates
About this site
 FAQ
 People are saying..
 Our purpose
 About us
 Techie stuff
 Contacting us

Established June 2, 1997
by citizens for citizens

Awards

March 16, 1998

Website of the Week
Daily Local News
August 13, 1997
  

A beautiful part of southeastern Pennsylvania

Kids Stuff Official Minutes Meeting Calendar Spcl Events Calendar Bulletin Board Neighbors of Note Neighborhood Issues Neighborhood News

Open Space Commission - Newsletter 2 - Fall/Winter 2002

Contents:

Open Space Pays
We can't deny it - Charlestown Township is clearly a desirable place to live. Based upon the number of applications either approved or pending, we could be adding 137 new, single family homes and 347 new townhouses within the next few years. What impact is this expected to have upon our township's population? How readily are we prepared to absorb the needs of these new residents within our existing traditional, emergency and educational municipal services and resources?
The issues facing our community are not new. The Penn State Cooperative Extension published the results of several studies attempting to quantify the relative costs of developmental patterns. The outcome was consistent. Residential development costs much more for municipal and school district costs than farming, commercial and industrial land uses. By far, non-residential or open space contributes more than it takes in governmental services.
In the eyes of our highly vocal developers, land is an asset, and it is fundamentally unfair for municipal officers to promote zoning techniques that reduce the value of that asset. Having made that astute observation, developers should be prepared to speculate upon the impact of community growth upon the average Charlestown Township resident. If we were to look at the results of some historical data, we would learn that the cost seven years ago to educate a public school student was $7,300 per year, and it was expected that each new home would produce, on average, about one additional school student. Let's look at the other side of the ledger - what's being generated in real estate tax revenues for each additional household? The tally was $2,700 or a shortfall of $4,600. That was based upon data analyzed seven years ago. Would we expect any less today?
Now, what options are open to our governing body? In 1996, an amendment to existing legislation broadened the powers of local government to acquire interests in real property to include recreation, scenic resources, historic sites and the conservation of national resources. Local leadership may levy a tax on real estate or earned income above existing limits to purchase development rights after receiving referendum approval from the voters. Not that we would expect our governing body to act impulsively, this provision clearly mandates that this option be accompanied with exhaustive analysis of the issue.
Are we involved in an adversarial situation with developers? I think not. We have to recognize the business objections of developers and correspondingly, mature thinking developers should acknowledge our preservation mission. Essentially,we are seeking fair balance, which does not include insensitively ravaging our community and going on to duplicate this outcome in neighborhood communities.
How have other municipalities fared? A recent study by the Heritage Conservancy disclosed a successful effort by Buckingham Township, Bucks County which had established a goal of preserving 20% of its land area. While the value of properties increase as resources become scarce, a well-planned and adequately funded acquisition program can be orchestrated to accommodate this natural economic trend. Another charge is that only rich landowners in affluent communities are beneficiaries. Numerous experiences of land rich but cash poor farmers would dispute this allegation.
Who needs more taxes? Isn't there another way? Most frequently a modest or even aggressive increase in real estate taxes just doesn't do the trick. How responsive are communities to increases in earned income? In studying the experience of four communities faced with this prospect, the referendum approval rate ranged from 71% to 93% with the median at 84%. Chester County had the most compelling need and floated a bond of $50 million five years ago, after receiving a resounding approval by 81% of their voters.
The very same source reminds us that the purchase of land or development rights will not stop either further development or the rising cost of education. However, it will blunt or neutralize the economic impact of rapid, all too frequently insensitive development which compromises the value of community assets. Can the state of Pennsylvania intervene and reduce the direct obligation of local residents?
Having described these avenues, we also have to face the reality that these funds come from taxes paid by homeowners and businesses throughout the Commonwealth, contributing to a highly competitive "horse race."
The people from the Williamstown Conservation Trust have cited the following four landowner benefits from land preservation easements:
  • Landowners participating in such programs extract immense personal satisfaction and psychic income from "doing the right thing" for future generations.
  • Conservation promotes planning, enabling families to bind together, evaluate all available options and avoid possible conflicts.
  • Extended protection frequently surfaces when neighboring landowners on contiguous properties share the benefits of protecting large resource areas, such as watersheds, agricultural areas and scenic landscapes.
  • Landowners who donate conservation easements may be eligible for significant financial aid through the reduction of federal income, gift and estate taxes.
We're committed and mobilized. Since the forming of the Open Space Commission one-year ago, we have heard numerous presentations by experts in the field. Remarkably, with few exceptions, architects of successful preservation outcomes are responsive to sharing their experiences. Our obligation is to listen, tailor the results to the needs of Charlestown Township, and establish a mechanism to keep informed. We invite your feedback. No, we urge your feedback. Can each of you who holds land that would impact how we live become a champion for doing the right thing? There is no reason why a "feel good" commitment cannot be shared.
Frank Corcoran
Open Space Commission member

What Is A Conservation Easement And How Can It Lower My Taxes?
Conservation Easements empower the residents of Charlestown Township to protect their land against future development. In fact, our state legislature has joined 48 other states by recently enacting a "Conservation and Preservation Easements Act" which authorizes conservation and historic preservation easements.
What is an easement? An easement is a way for a landowner to permanently control the future use of his or her property by agreeing to transfer some or all of his or her development rights to a land trust or governmental body. The landowner either sells or donates the development rights and permits a third party to enforce or "monitor" the easement for all time.
What is the purpose of an easement? The purpose of a conservation easement is to permanently protect the historic, natural, and/or agricultural values of land.
What are the benefits of creating a conservation easement? There are many benefits to a landowner who eases his or her land.
For example:
  • the landowner continues to have title to the property
  • the landowner continues to have the right to live on the property
  • the landowner continues to have the right to sell the property
  • the landowner continues to have the right to pass the property to heirs
  • the landowner continues to have the right to lease the property
  • the landowner may continue to have the right to subdivide the property
  • the landowner's income and/or gift and estate taxes may be reduced
  • the costs of preparing and easement are usually tax deductible
  • an easement agreement usually does not permit public access to the property
  • And lastly, the landowner knows the property will be protected for future generations.
Aliena J. Gerhard
Commission Member

Compelling Economic And Environmental Reasons Make Open Space Preservation Good Common Sense
On September 16th, the Chair of Charlestown's Open Space Commission, Andy Motel, reported to the Board of Supervisors on the Commission's activities and progress. What follow are excerpts from the report: excerpts that every Charlestown Resident should read because this affects all of us.
Why the emphasis on Open Space Preservation? Do we need it? Is it practical?
  1. Open space saves every taxpayer money. a widespread and very damaging fallacy in land development is that the development of raw land into residential units somehow "builds our tax revenue." This is not only false but in fact, the opposite is true: residential development raises everyone's taxes. Fewer services are required for open space (no kids in the schools, no extra cars to increase road maintenance, reduced need for a local police department, sewers or public water, etc.) In fact, according to several recent studies conducted by Penn State University, Open Space consumes in services only 8% of the tax dollar it pays, while a typical residential development consumes 112% of the tax dollar or 12% more in services than the tax dollars actually paid by the homeowners.
  2. Open Space helps our environment. Rain soaks through fields and woods to replenish our wells. Fewer homes, driveways and roads reduce runoff. Fewer homes mean fewer cars on the roads and cleaner air.
  3. Open Space in the form of fields, woods, streams, and trails is beautiful and relaxing.
  4. Keeping Charlestown beautiful through open space increases our property values.
Is Open Space in Charlestown really in danger? How much is there?
  1. The Open Space and the Planning Commissions estimate that there are about 1600 acres suitable for development left in Charlestown.
  2. Development pressure is IMMENSE! Weekly phone calls from potential developers to Charlestown's large landowners are routine.
  3. The list of development and development pressures on the books grows daily:
    • The Turnpike interchange on Rte 29 is scheduled for completion in 2007.
    • The Atwater Corporate Park on Rte 29 will add 8,000 to 12,000 jobs (read more commuters)
    • Spring Oak Corporate Park on White Horse Road in Devault will add 1600- 1800 more jobs.
    • Charlestown Meadows on Route 401 and Newcomen Road will result in 190 homes.
    • AND THERE WILL BE MORE!
Given all this pressure, is it possible to preserve any open space in Charlestown?
YES! YES! YES! With the support of Charlestown Residents.
  1. The Open Space and Planning Commissions estimate that we have a window of opportunity of 5 to no more than 10 years.
  2. Landowners can help the township to preserve open space by placing a conservation easement on their property or by selling development rights. In both instances, the landowner retains ownership of the property; but the possibility of building additional structures on the property is permanently limited. (Farms and homes with large acreage often appreciate in value when the land is protected. Properties that abut protected land also appreciate in value.)
  3. The estimated costs of preserving 100 acres annually through purchase of development rights is estimated at $1,800,000 ($18,000/acre). These costs can be reduced by matching grants from the County and the state, by outright donations from landowners (often a viable estate planning strategy), and by a variety of other means. However, Township dollars will be required as a match for grant funds, and for the related costs associated with ensuring that the eased land is protected as intended.
  4. Our current promise to two Charlestown families constitute more than we currently can afford under existing available funds. Additional projects require aggressive and very substantial funding. Most importantly, time is not on our side-we must act before we are simply priced out of the market.
What is our Township doing about it? The Board of Supervisors, by unanimous vote, established the Open Space Commission as an advisory board for the purpose of focusing Township efforts on the preservation of open space in Charlestown. The Commission has spent the past year striving to fulfill its mandate. It has:
  • Educated itself about the myriad opportunities and methods available to those landowners who wish they could preserve their land as open space.
  • Developed a resource list and collection of materials about land preservation. The resource list is available on the Citizens' website (http://www.charlestown.org); the materials are housed in the Township Office in Devault.
  • Distributed newsletters about open space (this is the second issue to be published) to Charlestown residents. (Comments, feedback for improvement are welcome!)
  • Maintained information about meetings, etc., on the Citizens' website.
  • Entered into a working relationship with two large landowners toward preserving their property as open space.
  • Written three grants for money to assist with these preservation efforts and to fund possible purchase of easements for the Horseshoe Trail, the latter as a collaboration with the Parks and Recreation Department (Grant decisions will be made this month.)
But, the Commission needs money in order to fulfill this mandate. Therefore, The Open Space Commission strongly recommends that the Board of Supervisors adopt a township tax strategy that will ensure that the matching money for Open Space preservation is available.

French And Pickering Creeks Conservation Trust, Inc.: Working With Townships To Preserve Open Spaces And Historic Places
Did you know that the French and Pickering Creek watersheds, located right here in Northern Chester County, contain some of the most scenic lands in Pennsylvania and are rich in sites of historic importance? Founded in 1967, F&P strives to preserve open space and historic sites in the watersheds of these two creeks. It has recently welcomed a new executive director, Jessica Dimuzio, VMD, who will contribute to the F&P's service to our Northern Chester County communities.
Among its myriad successes, including the conservation of over 7000 acres of land, F&P has worked in our Township to conserve open spaces. Through Ann Orth, F&P's Director of Land Preservation, F&P has worked with our Open Space Commission in applying for a grant through the Chester County Parks and Rec. Department's Preservation Partnership Program. F&P also organized the March 2002 meeting of area land trusts and commissions, featured in our last newsletter, and is hosting part of the recently completed Countryside Exchange, an important gathering concerning regional efforts to conserve land and sustain farming.
Did you know that the F&P Trust works with EASEMENTS? Just recently, the Trust closed on its purchase of a conservation easement on 51 environmentally sensitive acres above French Creek Road in nearby West Vincent Township. This land is home to rare and endangered plants and contains a section of an ancient and unusual geological escarpment! Funding for this important purchase came from township, county, and state sources. The Trust is now working with other area landowners who are interested in protecting their land so that there will be a contiguous block of protected woodland along the slopes above the French Creek.
F&P also has volunteers, like the writer of this article, who monitor prior easement acquisitions. Ann Orth joined me on a beautiful day last winter, and together, we monitored two properties in neighboring West Pikeland Township. I am fortunate to not only see first hand the tangible benefits of conservation easements but also to play an active role in working with F&P Trust in its tireless efforts to preserve our beautiful countryside. Look for F&P on the web at http://www.frenchandpickering.org.
Aliena J. Gerhard
Commission Member

Charlestown Cooperative Farm - Preserving Farming And Open Space In Charlestown
The Charlestown Cooperative Farm is a nonprofit cooperative recently established to preserve farming and open space in Charlestown. The cooperative is now operating a community supported farm at 2565 Charlestown Road on 40 acres which were part of the Fisher Farm. The Fisher Family, which owned and farmed this scenic property for over 100 years, had numerous opportunities to sell for development, but chose to do a wonderful thing for the community by selling part of its property for use and preservation as a farm. The Fisher family continues to live on the remainder of the farm where field crops are grown, and cattle graze in the pasture.
The newly acquired parcel is now in a transitional phase to organic vegetable farming. No chemical pesticides or her bicides will be used on the property in the future, and at the end of a mandated three year period, the farm will be certified organic. The cooperative is now building a timber frame bank barn on the property for its operation.
The bulk of the vegetables from the farm are distributed to families in the community who have bought shares in the output of the farm for the year, and the remainder are sold at the newly formed Phoenixville Farmers' Market which operates Saturdays from 9am until 2pm at Bridge and Main Streets in Phoenixville. Members of the cooperative can pick flowers, herbs, and certain vegetables at the farm, experiencing first hand the connection between the land and the food they eat.
The farm has been well received. All shares for the year sold quickly and more land will be planted in vegetables to expand the production for next year. Charlestown Cooperative Farm would like to expand its operation to include an organic grass based dairy operation and is now looking for a property to acquire and preserve for this use. Please visit the farm's website at http://www.charlestowncooperativefarm.org.

THANK-YOU TO OUR RESIDENTS FOR FILLING OUT OUR SURVEY!
Look For Upcoming Workshops On:
  • Historic House Maintenance
  • Wild Animals Of Charlestown
  • Estate Planning

Charlestown Township
Open Space Commission
P.O. Box 507
Devault, PA 19432
Open Space Commission Members:
Contact Information
Andy Motel - Chair
Bob Jones - Vice Chair
Sue Staas - Secretary
Bob Roggio - Financial Officer
Bill Andersen
Alix Coleman
Frank Corcoran
Aliena Gerhard
Mary Ellen Joos
Kevin Kuhn
Rosemary Philips
Marcia Solda
To contact any member of the Open Space Comission call the Township Office at 610-240-0326.
 

Home      Site Overview      Contact Us

Please report any problems with this site by clicking here.
Site development, maintenance and funding by Township resident Jacob D. Merriwether.
Hosting by PLH Worldgroup Communications, Inc.